He was perfect, but
not good enough
Harvey "The Kitten" Haddix played important roles in two of the baseball's best-remembered games.
Most recall Haddix for what has been called baseball's best pitching performance – when he retired 36 consecutive Milwaukee Brave batters on March 26, 1959, something which probably had him asking himself, "What the heck does a guy have to do to win a game for this team?"
By 1959 Haddix was with his fourth major league team, the Pittsburgh Pirates, and coming off two mediocre seasons (with Philadelphia and Cincinnati). Suddenly, he was perfect – through 12 innings against the Braves. The good news: he was making major league history. The bad news: he was getting no support from his teammates who failed to score off the Braves' Lew Burdette. The remarkable news: the Braves knew in advance every pitch Haddix threw that evening. (See Smoky Burgess.)
Burdette kept his shutout in the top of the 13th inning. Felix Mantilla opened the bottom of the inning by reaching base on an error by Pirate third baseman Don Hoak. So long, perfect game, but the no-hitter was still alive. Mantilla was sacrificed to second base and Haddix intentionally walked Hank Aaron.
Up stepped Joe Adcock who hit the ball over the fence in right-centerfield. Game over; Haddix loses, but not without a bonehead play by Aaron, who trotted off the field after passing second base rather than run all the way home. Aaron was called out and Adcock's "home run" was reduced to a double. Final score: 1-0.
Haddix finished the season with 12 wins, 12 losses. A year later the Pirates won the National League pennant and beat the New York Yankees in the World Series. Haddix picked up two wins, including Game Seven, when he came in to pitch the final inning in what generally is regarded as the wildest, most exciting World Series finale ever, won by the Pirates, 10-9, on a home run in the bottom of the ninth by Bill Mazeroski. |