PART TWO

The cases proceeded, threatening to overwhelm two local judges. The Auburn Citizen seemed to be enjoying the situation. Unfortunately, there was no byline on any of their stories, even those written in a subjective, slightly derisive style that was allowed, probably encouraged during that period in American journalism, when, frankly, newspapers were a lot more interesting than they would be after graphic designers invaded the business and "improved" newspaper appearance and writers became shackled by political correctness. Are newspapers better looking than they were 100 years ago? Certainly. Are the stories more balanced? You betcha. But no newspaper today is as lively and interesting as those from the first half of the 20th century. They were eyesores, perhaps, but like horrible accidents, they commanded and held your attention.

What jumped out at me in the following piece were (1) that an accuser would be selected as a potential juror in the case of the accused, (2) the amusing retaliatory steps taken by pro-baseball people and (3) how the newspaper described two Polish-American men involved in an unrelated case. (Some of us do take exception to the P word, you know.)

It also seems one of the judges involved in this affair, Isaac E. Pearson, already was in need of a long, long vacation.

 
Auburn Citizen, Monday May 26, 1913
BUSIEST JUSTICE

In Cayuga County Is Pearson
of Owasco

WITH DE GROFF RUNNER UP

Agitation Against Sunday Baseball
and Numerous Arrests
Largely Responsible

The busiest justice of the peace in Cayuga County at the present time is Isaac E. Pearson of the town of Owasco with Justice DeGroff runner-up. The officials have plenty of work ahead for the next month disposing of arrests made in the Sunday baseball agitations and in addition Justice Pearson is beginning his annual sessions for various offenses committed about the foot of the [Owasco] lake on Sundays and other occasions.

Saturday Justice Pearson was busy adjusting bail and other details connected with the arrest of the 18 members of the All-Auburn and Norwood baseball teams on warrants charging them with riot growing out of the stopping of the game at Norwood one week ago yesterday. On three days, June 4, 6 and 7, the players will appear and then decide whether they will have an examination or waive and be held for the Grand Jury.

When this procedure was over, the players were brought before Justic DeGroff at the Two Mile House* in Fleming to be arraigned on warrants charging violation of law, Sunday baseball playing. Justice DeGroff was not posted on all the fine points of the law regarding his duties, but well along in the evening had disposed of all the cases.

The players were represented by Attorneys Charles A. Wright and Francis C. Raines and the People by Henry D. Parsell. The players pleaded not guilty and demanded a jury trial separately. The Fleming justice will be busy with baseball trials nearly every day next month. Nineteen juries have been drawn by the Fleming justices and some of the jurors have been drawn on as many as four panels. Clarence Post, one of the complainants against Sunday baseball, was drawn in two of the cases. All of the players are out on bail.

The first trial of Sunday baseball violations will be held before Justice of the Peace Wyckoff in Fleming on Wednesday. The case is that of Manager Arthur O’Connor of the All-Auburn team. He will be defended by Attorney Frank M. Leary.

Yesterday Justice Pearson had other troubles besides the baseball question. Auctioneer Byron V. Baker came into his office and after laying down a “two bit” piece, asked for a warrant to arrest all of the members of the Country Club for Sunday golf playing on their fine preserve in Owasco. Justice Pearson directed Baker to furnish him with a list of the persons playing golf, and make the usual depositions and he would act at once in the case.

Baker was insistent that the club members should be arrested and that the justice get their names from the County Clerk’s Office. Then Justice Pearson got riled and ordered Baker from his office. Justice Pearson said this morning that if he had had any officers handy at the time that he would have locked up Baker.

The Law Enforcement Committee of the Bible School Union has sent a communication to the Country Club officers requesting the members of that organization to cooperate in having the laws pertaining to the observance of Sunday observed.

Then the pleasure of a bunch of jolly Englishmen enjoying a little cricket practice among themselves on the Melrose court jarred the sensitive nerves of Owasco residents.

Herbert D. Rhodes, a youngster living in First Avenue, made complaint to Justice Pearson regarding the cricket practice and asked for the issuance of warrants. Rhodes could not give the names of the players, a condition exacted by Justice Pearson before he will issue warrants, and none was issued. Rhodes will take the matter up with the Bible School Committee.

This morning Stanley J. Majeki and John Subry, Polacks arrested last evening for running a team of horses recklessly along the Owasco road, were in a penitent mood. They had been to a Polish christening in the town of Fleming during the day and had imbibed too freely.

The men did not know anything about the commotion they raised last evening and both promised to drink “never again.” Both pleaded guilty to charges of public intoxication and paid fines of $10 each.

Then Majeki was arrested on a warrant charging cruelty to animals on complaint of Superintendent Doyle of the Humane Society. The Polack entered a plea of guilty and paid a fine of $10.

Along in the evening two men detained for intoxication in the yard of Justice Pearson were rescued by a crowd of half a dozen rowdies and all got back to Auburn.

Justice Pearson announced emphatically this morning that any of the rowdy element which makes a practice of coming to the lake Sunday and spoil the pleasure of others will get soaked to the very limit of the law. He stated that he knew some of the gang last night and if they appear in the town of Owasco this Summer they will not return to Auburn free men.

Justice Pearson stated that he was going to give any rowdies arrested this Summer a chance for a little confinement “and it won’t be a 10-day bit either."

[The town of Owasco borders on the city of Auburn and sits on the east side of Owasco Lake, one of New York's Finger Lakes. Across the lake, also bordering on Auburn, is the town of Fleming.

Also, Two Mile House* in the town of Fleming originally was a lakeside hotel, but had a checkered history. Arrests had been made there for prostitution and for cockfighting. However, it did have a room that was large enough for the court proceedings which had outgrown the parlor of Justice DeGroff's home.]

The following newspaper story apparently refers to what was the source of the complaint made by Herbert D. Rhodes:
Auburn Citizen, Monday, May 26, 1913
GOOD CRICKET PRACTICE
The members of the Auburn Cricket Club showed fine form at practice at Melrose Court yesterday afternoon. A team captained by William H. Bailey was victorious by a score of 53 runs to 10. The practice gave the club men confidence that they will defeat the strong British-American team at Rochester on Memorial Day.
 

Elsewhere in the Auburn Citizen that day was this amusing observation:

"That Justice DeGroff will have some difficulty in taking care of his crops is evidenced by the fact there is a trial set to take place on nearly every day during the month of June."

Sunday, May 25, was a day of rest for players from the Norwood team; they had been scheduled to play at home against a team from Seneca Falls in a State Amateur League game, but the managers opted to postpone the contest. The real reason was the Bible Union Group; one of the sports stories that day claimed the game was called on account of wet grounds.

There was another interesting piece of news in the Auburn Citizen that day, a story that might have indicated how the local baseball war was merely part of a larger crusade:

In the Cincinnati suburb of Wyoming, population about 3,000, a group called the Moral Uplift Committee made a house-to-house canvass in an attempt to pressure people to attend church on Sunday. The committee claimed to have counted everyone in Wyoming and reported that only 30 residents out of the entire population did not attend church "and these were ill."

There were Go To Church Days in other communities in 1913 and 1914, though I'm not sure whether house-to-house canvassing was involved.

MEANWHILE, in Syracuse, the All-Auburn nine did play a league game on Sunday, May 25, against a team called The Moose Club. There was no church group in Syracuse trying to shut down Sunday baseball, though The Moose Club probably wouldn't have objected if this game had been stopped, and stopped early. All-Auburn beat the Moosers, 33-1. That score is not a typo.

Oh, yes, baseball did resume inside the Auburn city limits. Teams called the Harriers and Swamp Athletic Club went at each other for 14 innings at the Standart Heights field in a game that ended in a 3-all tie. It was the first contest of a five-game series between the teams. The Auburn Citizen reported the game was arranged the night before and the teams did not advertise the contest. Still a large crowd was on hand to witness the game, which, according to the Citizen story, featured "snappy fielding" and "many sensational catches."

For an entertaining account of what happened in Auburn that day, keep going.

 
The saga continues . . .
 
 
Previous story   Next story
 


Contact: JMajor9863@aol.com
Home
Read About It index