Bernie Carr and his dog, Holly, jog the Sandy Pond
beach on a foggy day several years ago.

 

Lure of a Lifetime

By Bernie Carr

Carl Island is the name of the island off Green Point. It was near Carl Island that my second wife and I frequently fished for black bass and rock bass. A spinner known as a #4 Mepps Bucktail was a favored lure for fishing bass; we always purchased two of every lure we both liked. One day we were having exceptional luck, but had to leave early because the fish had bitten the bucktail off my spinner. All the local places were sold out, so that night I cut some hair from the tail of my dog, Holly. I took some regular red sewing thread, attached it where the bucktail had been and placed some epoxy on it.

The next day my wife told me that since I had the lure that lost the hair, I had to use the imitation. I did. Was she sorry! That day I caught fish almost every cast. Hank Hayes, “fisherman extra ordinary”, moved his boat to be near me. Shortly he was casting where I was. I caught five to his one. I switched sides of the boat. I looked up and there he was again. He asked what I was using. I told him a Mepps #4 Bucktail. He asked me if I was doing something different or if I had placed fish oil on the Mepps. I told him no.

My wife was getting tired of me catching most of the fish and wanted to return to camp. As soon as we returned, she asked me to take the bucktail off her spinner and add some Holly Hair to it.
That night I had a visit from Hank, who finally got the secret from me. If I agreed, he would have purchased every hair Holly had. I did agree to provide him enough hair to do one spinner each year free. He agreed not to tell where he got it.

Members of my family with little fishing experience became experts. I still only took that which Holly's tail would reasonably provide. She was a lady.

When my wife and I decided to go our separate ways, she asked me to take Holly. The winter after I started work in Fulton, I needed an apartment. I could find no one who would take dogs, so a friend offered to keep Holly until I could find a place that would, or until I moved to the Pond that spring.

Shortly thereafter, Holly ran away, I believe to find me. We searched everywhere, placed ads, checked the Humane Society and I ran the roads for weeks looking. We never found her. Every time I opened the door that year at the Pond, I expected to see her. A couple of years later, there were no Holly Hair spinners remaining.

Years later my dad had colon cancer and was told he had about six months to live. I was the oldest of his children and we talked often about what he would like to do. His first need was to get his affairs in order and he wanted me to see that his wishes were adhered to. Next he wished to finish his life as long as possible as if he was healthy. He then held a little party for a few of us at Sandy Pond to tell us old stories, why he had done certain things and little secrets he thought we should know. That day he became more outgoing then he ever was before or after. He also told me that after his services, he wanted the first of his monies to be spent on a party for all those who attended those services to celebrate the good things in his life.

Finally, he said he had something special for me, but that I would have to promise to use it and place it on the mantle somewhere. You guessed it – the last Holly Hair. It isn't on the mantle. What is left of it is in a square, white marble urn.

Love's True Test

In the early Spring after the first warm rain, the Lake Ontario bull heads come into the creeks to spawn. They are the best eating when they feed in colder water and above the sand. River bullheads often have a muddy taste. The best time to fish is between 8 and 11 p.m.

Years ago, I normally used two poles from the shore, each on forked sticks pushed into the ground. Each pole had two hooks, each hook with a juicy night-walker (worm). In approximately half-hour stints the fish would bite so frequently that you could not keep both poles baited and in the water. (I later learned to pre-bait detachable hook sets to enhance my total catch, but still could not keep the poles baited and in the water for those busy periods). I often caught around 40 one- to two-pound fish in an evening. On some occassions I would go home, switch gear and go to another creek from about 1 to 3 a.m. and blind dip for smelt with a net. Fresh smelt were my favorite.

Not long after I met my present wife, I took her with me to fish for bullhead. It was rainy and cool. For a half-hour we would cuddle together under some dock boards. The next half-hour was devoted to keeping up with the fish. Then cuddle again, then fish, then cuddle, then fish . . . We had a great time.

The next morning I was cleaning fish. She came out and asked if I would like fresh fish for lunch. I told her yes and gave her a couple. (For those not familiar, a bullhead is like a small catfish. They have skin, not scales. To clean, you remove the skin, the head, and all but the meat and bone. They have one main bone with the body bones attached. When you cook them, you do so with the bone in and just pull it away with one movement when they are cooked.)

My wife is from Long Island and was unfamiliar with cooking fresh water fish. She asked me how I liked bullheads prepared. I explained that my sister used pancake flour and then pan-fried them, and her way was my favorite.

A while later my wife announced that lunch was ready. I went to the table expecting the tender white meat encased in a crisp coating of oil-fried pancake flour and egg. What I saw was a large pancake with the form of a bullhead in the middle. (She could not get the flour to stick to the fish so she made a batter, which also didn't stick. The pancake cooked, the fish did not. I still ate it, though I believe I have not had fried bullhead since.)

It’s 33 years later and my wife still tells everyone that after she saw me eat that fish she knew my love was real. (She has since became a good cook.)

Bernie Carr has his own website: www.sandypondny.com

 

More Sandy Pond ...

 
1
Paradise Found
ALSO:  
2 Head for the Hill Bernie Carr's stories
Climb It No More The Ice Cometh / The Fishing Expert
3 Frozen in Time Ooops!
4 The Rise and Fall Lure of a Lifetime / Love's True Test
What Really Happened ... Bernie's website: www.sandypondny.com
5 Ever Hopeful  
6 Nature's Reward Other Sandy Pond websites:
7 Sandy Pond Today www.sandypondresorts.com
8 Feedback from the Faithful www.spcma.homestead.com
www/pulaskinychamber.com
  Contact us: JMajor9863@aol.com